Tribunal rules fear of catching Covid-19 is not a protected belief

By Brabners LLP

13 Jan 2022

shutterstock_1658927440.jpg

As cases that have arisen as a result of decisions being made during the Covid-19 pandemic begin to reach the Employment Tribunal, we are getting a clearer understanding of how established principles of employment law will be applied to some of the unique challenges of the past two years.

Most recently, the Tribunal decided that a fear of contracting Covid-19 was not sufficient to amount to a ‘philosophical belief’ and therefore did not attract the protection of the Equality Act 2010.

In the case of X v Y [2020], the Employment Tribunal was asked to consider whether a fear of becoming infected with Covid-19 was a legally protected belief.

In accordance with the Equality Act 2010, employees are entitled to protection against unlawful discrimination on account of their religion or belief. ‘Belief’ is deemed to include any religious or philosophical belief, or a lack thereof.

In order to be protected, a philosophical belief must be genuinely held and amount to more than simply an opinion. The belief must relate to a weighty and substantial aspect of human life and behaviour and be cogent, serious, cohesive and important. There is also a requirement that such a belief be worthy of respect in a democratic society, and not affect other people’s fundamental rights.

Previously, pacifism and ethical veganism have been recognised as protected philosophical beliefs, however, in this case the Tribunal decided that a fear of catching Covid-19 was not sufficient to be protected.

Facts

On 31 July 2020, the Claimant, an employee of the Respondent, decided that she would not return to the workplace as she felt that she had ‘reasonable and justifiable health and safety concern’ in that she had a genuine concern that she would catch Covid-19 in the workplace. This was further compounded that she feared she could pass this on to her ‘high risk’ partner.

The Claimant raised these concerns with her employer, asserting that she reasonably believed she and her partner faced a serious and imminent health and safety danger. The Claimant therefore sought to assert her health and safety rights under the Employment Rights Act 1996.

The employer refused to accept her assertions and withheld wages until the Claimant agreed to return to work. The Claimant alleged that this behaviour amounted to direct discrimination as a result of a philosophical belief.

Decision

The Tribunal accepted that the Claimant’s fear that she could become infected with Covid-19 and subsequently infect her partner was genuinely held, but it refused to find that such a fear was a ‘belief’ in accordance with the Equality Act 2010.

The Tribunal accepted that the fear was cogent, serious, cohesive and important, it was worthy of respect in a democratic society and did not conflict with the fundamental rights of others.

Despite this, the Tribunal found that a ‘reaction’ to a perceived or real threat (physical or otherwise), even if there was a general consensus that the reaction was appropriate, would be more properly described as a widely held opinion rather than a belief. Views on how to best reduce risk of physical harm could not amount to a belief, and therefore a fear of becoming infected with Covid-19 and how to best reduce risk of infection not a philosophical belief.

Furthermore, the Tribunal held that although the fear of the harm caused by Covid-19 is in itself weighty and substantial, as the specific fear in this case only related to the Claimant herself and her partner, it was not wide enough to be weighty and substantial to human life.

The Tribunal therefore dismissed the claim.

What does this mean for Employers and Employees?

It is important to note that this ruling was a first instance decision at the Employment Tribunal, so it is not binding on any other Court or Tribunal. It is unclear at this stage whether the Claimant intends to appeal the decision.

It is widely reported that there has been a significant growth in the number of individuals unable to attend work due to positive Covid-19 results. This growth has coincided with the Omicron variant which has a higher transmissibility than previous variants of Covid-19. Although there are temporary Plan B measures in place in the UK, as more individuals are required to return to workplaces or return from remote-working arrangements there is significant scope for disputes to arise.

Where employees show a reluctance to return to work and cite fear of becoming infected with Covid-19, employers should consider whether there are practical steps which can be taken to help alleviate the main causes of concern. For example, if the concern relates to using public transport during the commute the employer may allow flexible start and finish times to avoid busier periods. If employees are concerned about social distancing at work, employers may consider phased returns to reduce the number of employees in the workplace at any one time. In some cases, reasonable adjustments may be required.

While the Claimant in X v Y was unsuccessful in her claim, withholding pay or dismissal of an employee carries the risk of other claims including automatic unfair dismissal (for health and safety reasons) and discrimination where the employee possesses a protected characteristic (such as disability, pregnancy, age, or religion). Although employers may be able to successfully defend a decision to dismiss or withhold wages, it is vital that a clear, lawful process be adopted to reduce risk of liability and reputational damage.

To discuss how you or your business can deal with employee hesitance in returning to the workplace, please contact our Employment Team.

Latest news

1

PM urged not to retaliate over tariffs Manufacturing

PM urged not to retaliate over tariffs

03 Apr 2025

2

CMAC Group appoints Matthew Ratcliffe as chief operating officer Matthew Ratcliffe CMAC

CMAC Group appoints Matthew Ratcliffe as chief operating officer

03 Apr 2025

3

For sale signs at The Villa Villa Wrea Green has been brought to market (Image credit: The Villa Wrea Green)

For sale signs at The Villa

02 Apr 2025

4

Montane group expands with new Lancashire hub Anthony Rae Scott Murcott And Adam Lee

Montane group expands with new Lancashire hub

02 Apr 2025

5

Trio of wins for Lancaster brand and digital consultancy Tom Grattan MD and Daniel Wallace

Trio of wins for Lancaster brand and digital consultancy

02 Apr 2025

Pc Prestonmacan Gif980x120 March
Background image for hub sign up block

LBV Hub

Leverage Lancashire Business View platforms

Post your news
Post your events
Post your offers
Build your network
Improve your SEO
Gain coverage in the magazine
Sign-up
Events
Lancashire Net Zero Carbon Conference
Net Zero Carbon Social 1200px
Networking
18 Jun 2025

Lancashire Net Zero Carbon Conference

Crow Wood Hotel & Spa Resort, Burnley, BB12 0RT

08:30 - 13:00

CMI Level 5 Management and Leadership Course
UCLanAerialCampus.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
21 Feb 2025 - 21 Feb 2026

CMI Level 5 Management and Leadership Course

Preston Campus, Preston , PR1 2HE

09:00 - 17:00

CMI Level 5 Project Management Course
UCLanAerialCampus.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
21 Feb 2025 - 21 Feb 2026

CMI Level 5 Project Management Course

Preston Campus, Preston, PR1 2HE

08:00 - 17:00

RISE - The Academy for Female Leaders and Managers
WENDY BOWERS RISE Illustrstion copy.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
02 Apr 2025 - 08 Oct 2025

RISE - The Academy for Female Leaders and Managers

East Lancashire Chamber of Commerce, Clayton le Moors, BB5 5JR

09:00 - 15:30

Lancashire Business Expo 2025
https---cdn.evbuc.com-images-880395853-4862066883-1-original.20241022-091152-2.jpeg.jpg
LBV Hub Exhibitions
04 Apr 2025 - 04 Apr 2025

Lancashire Business Expo 2025

Sir Tom Finney Sports Centre, Preston, PR1 2HE

09:00 - 15:00

The Business Network Central & East Lancashire
LBV Hub Networking
24 Apr 2025 - 24 Apr 2025

The Business Network Central & East Lancashire

Stanley House, Blackburn, BB2 7NP

11:30 - 14:15

People Power: Exclusive Event Series
Stay ahead in 2025.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
29 Apr 2025 - 29 Apr 2025

People Power: Exclusive Event Series

People's History Museum, Manchester, M3 3ER

17:00 - 21:00

Planning for the future + navigating Inheritance Tax changes
Planning for the future + navigating Inheritance Tax changes for website.png.png
LBV Hub Seminars
01 May 2025 - 01 May 2025

Planning for the future + navigating Inheritance Tax changes

Stanley House Hotel, Mellor, Blackburn, BB2 7NP, Blackburn, BB2 7NP

08:00 - 10:30

A night at the races
1.png.png
LBV Hub Dinners / Balls
02 May 2025 - 02 May 2025

A night at the races

Morecambe FC, Morecambe, LA4 4TB

19:00 - 23:59

Innovating business solutions through PhD Partnerships
30478 Skills Bootcamp open day setting.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Networking
07 May 2025 - 07 May 2025

Innovating business solutions through PhD Partnerships

University of Central Lancashire, Preston , PR1 2HE

14:30 - 15:30

Celebrating 50 years of KTP
UCLanAerialCampus.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Networking
07 May 2025 - 07 May 2025

Celebrating 50 years of KTP

University of Central Lancashire , Preston, PR1 2HE

16:00 - 18:00

Research and Knowledge Exchange Showcase
13421_research_knowledge_exchange_2025_600x300.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Awards
07 May 2025 - 08 May 2025

Research and Knowledge Exchange Showcase

University of Central Lancashire , Preston, PR1 2HE

09:00 - 17:00

Advertise with us

Reaching 50,000 members, our print, digital and event platforms offer a fantastic way to raise your business profile and help you grow.

Find out more Lbv121 Online Graphic
Subscribe now

Weekly news bulletin