The ironic case of Lord Templeman’s will

By Brabners LLP

30 Jun 2022

shutterstock_451268143.jpg

Claims brought to challenge the validity of a testator’s will based on a lack of testamentary capacity are heavily reliant upon evidence, whether that be from friends and family members or from experts.

If a person challenging the will can prove that on balance, the testator was likely to have lacked the requisite testamentary capacity at the time the will was executed, then the court will be expected to declare the will to be invalid.

Accordingly, it was recognised in the case of Kenward v Adams [1975] that in some cases more consideration must be given to a testator’s mental capacity at the time instructions are taken. In his judgment, Lord Templeman established the ‘Golden Rule’ which provides that where a testator is elderly or has been ill, the will ought to be witnessed or approved by a medical practitioner who is satisfied as to the capacity and understanding of the testator.

Quite ironically however, Lord Templeman’s own capacity to make a will later became the subject of a dispute following his death in 2014. The claim was brought by Lord Templeman’s son, Michael who sought to have the 2014 will set aside on the basis that his father lacked testamentary capacity.

The crux of the dispute related to the property (known as ‘Mellowstone’) which Lord Templeman shared with his second wife, Sheila. By his 2001 will (and subsequent Codicil dated 2004), legacies were provided for each of his six grandchildren, together with £120,000 to Sheila’s two daughters, Jane and Sarah with any greater value of Mellowstone falling into his residuary estate to be shared between his two sons, Michael and Peter. By his 2008 will however, the legacies to the grandchildren had been removed and instead, Jane and Sarah were due to benefit from Mellowstone entirely with the residuary estate passing to Michael and Peter.

Michael argued that his father’s memory began to deteriorate by May 2006, which was later found to be the early stages of Alzheimer’s disease (as supported by medical evidence). It was also said that Lord Templeman was grief-stricken following the death of Sheila shortly before he executed the 2008 will, and contemporaneous evidence suggested that grief had exacerbated his condition (albeit he was undiagnosed at the time). Nonetheless, Lord Templeman provided instructions to his solicitor to prepare the 2008 will.

Remarkably, whilst the solicitor did recognise that Lord Templeman’s short-term memory had declined, the solicitor was satisfied from his own judgment that Lord Templeman was of sufficiently sound mind to execute the 2008 will. In essence, Lord Templeman’s solicitor had failed to follow the Golden Rule which Lord Templeman himself had established.

In considering the case, Mr Justice Fancourt did eventually find that Lord Templeman had the requisite testamentary capacity to execute the 2008 will having regard to an expert report obtained post-death. Whilst not surprised that the solicitor did not refer Lord Templeman for a medical assessment having taken into consideration his intellectual capacity and reputation, Mr Justice Fancourt did reiterate the importance of following the Golden Rule. Undoubtedly, this was the foundation upon which the litigation had been borne at a significant cost to all parties which could otherwise have been avoided.

Further information regarding contesting a will is available on our website. Alternatively, please contact a member of our contentious probate team who would be happy to assist.

Brabners in Lancashire is located at Sceptre Court, Walton Summit. If you would like to discuss anything raised in this article, please give us a ring on 01772 823921, quote “LBV” and a member of our team will be happy to assist you.  

If you would like to receive more content like this, please head to our website where you can subscribe to receive regular updates of current articles and events. 

Latest news

1

Northstone secures full planning permission for 50 new homes in Edenfield Edenfield housing development

Northstone secures full planning permission for 50 new homes in Edenfield

29 Apr 2025

2

Ring Stones Maintenance and Construction celebrates completion of Dovestone Gardens Dovestone Gardens launch

Ring Stones Maintenance and Construction celebrates completion of Dovestone Gardens

29 Apr 2025

3

PHX Training welcomes new business leader to drive learner success Louise Kirby

PHX Training welcomes new business leader to drive learner success

29 Apr 2025

4

Lidl to invest half a billion pounds in its expansion as it eyes sites in Lancashire Lidl

Lidl to invest half a billion pounds in its expansion as it eyes sites in Lancashire

29 Apr 2025

5

Inspired board reject takeover bid from major shareholder inspired-500x500.png

Inspired board reject takeover bid from major shareholder

29 Apr 2025

Pc Prestonmacan Gif980x120 March
Background image for hub sign up block

LBV Hub

Leverage Lancashire Business View platforms

Post your news
Post your events
Post your offers
Build your network
Improve your SEO
Gain coverage in the magazine
Sign-up
Events
LBV122 May/June Launch Event
121 Lancashire Business View Magazine Launch
Networking
21 May 2025

LBV122 May/June Launch Event

Lancaster and Morecambe College, Lancaster, LA1 2TY

08:30 - 10:30

Sub36 Networking
Networking
11 Jun 2025

Sub36 Networking

British Jewellery School, Scorton, PR3 1BA

15:00 - 17:00

Lancashire Net Zero Carbon Conference
Net Zero Carbon Social 1200px 2
Networking
18 Jun 2025

Lancashire Net Zero Carbon Conference

Crow Wood Hotel & Spa Resort, Burnley, BB12 0RT

08:30 - 13:00

Lancashire Built Environment Conference 2025
BEC 315 X 315 Px
Networking
25 Sep 2025

Lancashire Built Environment Conference 2025

Blackpool Football Club, Blackpool, FY1 6HX

08:30 - 13:00

CMI Level 5 Management and Leadership Course
UCLanAerialCampus.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
21 Feb 2025 - 21 Feb 2026

CMI Level 5 Management and Leadership Course

Preston Campus, Preston , PR1 2HE

09:00 - 17:00

CMI Level 5 Project Management Course
UCLanAerialCampus.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
21 Feb 2025 - 21 Feb 2026

CMI Level 5 Project Management Course

Preston Campus, Preston, PR1 2HE

08:00 - 17:00

RISE - The Academy for Female Leaders and Managers
WENDY BOWERS RISE Illustrstion copy.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
02 Apr 2025 - 08 Oct 2025

RISE - The Academy for Female Leaders and Managers

East Lancashire Chamber of Commerce, Clayton le Moors, BB5 5JR

09:00 - 15:30

Planning for the future + navigating Inheritance Tax changes
Planning for the future + navigating Inheritance Tax changes for website.png.png
LBV Hub Seminars
01 May 2025 - 01 May 2025

Planning for the future + navigating Inheritance Tax changes

Stanley House Hotel, Mellor, Blackburn, BB2 7NP, Blackburn, BB2 7NP

08:00 - 10:30

A night at the races
1.png.png
LBV Hub Dinners / Balls
02 May 2025 - 02 May 2025

A night at the races

Morecambe FC, Morecambe, LA4 4TB

19:00 - 23:59

Advantage: AI – A Workshop for Business Leaders – May 2
EV-land-2025-05B.png.png
LBV Hub Seminars
02 May 2025 - 02 May 2025

Advantage: AI – A Workshop for Business Leaders – May 2

Door4 Office, Burnley Wharf, Manchester Road, Burnley, BB11 1JG

09:00 - 11:00

Innovating business solutions through PhD Partnerships
30478 Skills Bootcamp open day setting.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Networking
07 May 2025 - 07 May 2025

Innovating business solutions through PhD Partnerships

University of Central Lancashire, Preston , PR1 2HE

14:30 - 15:30

Celebrating 50 years of KTP
UCLanAerialCampus.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Networking
07 May 2025 - 07 May 2025

Celebrating 50 years of KTP

University of Central Lancashire , Preston, PR1 2HE

16:00 - 18:00

Advertise with us

Reaching 50,000 members, our print, digital and event platforms offer a fantastic way to raise your business profile and help you grow.

Find out more Lbv121 Online Graphic
Subscribe now

Weekly news bulletin