The holiday pay saga continues; but is the end in sight

By Brabners LLP

19 Jan 2023

Simon Lbv Image

The latest development in the law on holiday pay sees the government announce a consultation on a proposal to overturn the controversial judgment in the case of Harpur Trust v Brazel.

THE CURRENT LEGAL POSITION

In July 2022, the Supreme Court issued its judgment in the long-running case of Harpur Trust v Brazel regarding the correct calculation of annual leave and holiday pay for employees with irregular working patterns.

The Supreme Court ruled that employees on permanent contracts who only work for part of the year, such as seasonal workers or teachers, should receive the same statutory holiday entitlement (5.6 weeks per year) as employees who work the full year.

This means that employers should not pro-rate the holiday entitlement of “part-year” workers so that it is proportionate to the amount of work they actually do. In particular, the Supreme Court ruled that holiday entitlement and holiday pay should not be calculated using the 12.07 per cent accrual method, which is commonly used to calculate holiday entitlement for employees with variable working hours, as it is not accurate when applied to “part-year” workers.

The judgment, which concerned the correct interpretation of the Working Time Regulations 1998 (“WTR”), has proved controversial and counter-intuitive, meaning that someone who only works for one week but is employed on a permanent contract for a full year, is entitled to 5.6 weeks’ holiday (and holiday pay) in the same way as someone who works all year round. 

The decision has proved tricky for employers to implement in practice, particularly umbrella companies, agencies who employ agency workers and those companies that use casual workers. If holiday entitlement cannot be calculated as 12.07 per cent of the hours worked, then how should it be calculated? The Supreme Court did not give an answer to that question. 

THE PROPOSAL

Acknowledging the apparent unfairness created by the Harpur Trust decision, as well as the difficulties for both employers and employees in understanding exactly how much holiday a particular employee is entitled to, the government has announced a proposal to change the law so that holiday entitlement for part-year and irregular hours workers will be pro-rated based on the hours they actually work. This proposal would effectively overturn the Supreme Court’s decision in the Harpur Trust case.

The government is inviting businesses, workers and representative bodies to submit their views on its proposal by way of a consultation which will be open until 9 March 2023.

In summary, the government’s proposal is as follows:

  1. Employers will be able to calculate a worker’s holiday entitlement as 12.07 per cent of the hours that they have actually worked in the previous 52 weeks;
  2. The 52-week reference period would correspond with the employer’s holiday year, meaning that at the beginning of a new leave year, the employee’s holiday entitlement for that year would be calculated based on the hours which they worked in the preceding leave year. This would give the worker a fixed pot of annual leave (expressed in hours) that they would then be able to draw from throughout the leave year;
  3. For employees in the first year of their job, their holiday entitlement would be calculated at the end of each month based on the actual hours worked in that month. This accrual-based system would only be required for the first year of employment until the 52-week entitlement reference period could be used;
  4. To calculate how many hours’ holiday will be used by taking a particular day off, the employer would work out how many hours the employee worked on average in a day in the preceding holiday year, then when the employee takes a day off, they would take off the number of hours calculated from this average working day.

In relation to agency workers, the government proposes that they would not accrue holiday entitlement when they are not working on an assignment. It is proposed that their holiday entitlement would be calculated in the same way as for other irregular hours workers who are in their first year of employment (see point 3 above), i.e the employment business or umbrella company would calculate the agency worker’s entitlement as 12.07 per cent of the hours that they had worked over the previous month of an assignment, or at the end of an assignment (if shorter than a month).

However, where agency workers have a contract of employment with an umbrella company that is longer than a year or they work on one assignment that lasts longer than a year, their statutory holiday entitlement would be calculated by using the 52-week reference period set out at point 2 above.

The government’s proposal is only at consultation stage, so it is possible that the proposed calculations set out above may change, or the proposal may not even come into effect at all. However, the confusion caused by the Harpur Trust decision, and the practical difficulties with implementing it in practice, leads us to believe that the law in relation to holidays for irregular hours workers will change in some way in the not-too-distant future.

One question which arises from the government’s proposed approach to holiday entitlement (i.e calculating it by reference to hours worked) is how it will affect the accrual of holiday during periods of sickness absence or family leave when the employee has not worked. It is currently a well-established legal principle that employees on sick leave and maternity leave continue to accrue holiday entitlement, but the calculation proposed in the consultation document does not appear to account for such scenarios. It will therefore be important to see how the proposal translates into legislation (if it does at all).

For the time being, employers who were considering changing their contractual models and holiday pay calculations might consider postponing any plans until after the outcome of the consultation is known.

Brabners in Lancashire is located at Sceptre Court, Walton Summit. If you would like to discuss anything raised in this article, please give us a ring on 01772 823921, quote “LBV” and a member of our team will be happy to assist you.  

If you would like to receive more content like this, please head to our website where you can subscribe to receive regular updates of current articles and events.

Latest news

1

PM urged not to retaliate over tariffs Manufacturing

PM urged not to retaliate over tariffs

03 Apr 2025

2

CMAC Group appoints Matthew Ratcliffe as chief operating officer Matthew Ratcliffe CMAC

CMAC Group appoints Matthew Ratcliffe as chief operating officer

03 Apr 2025

3

For sale signs at The Villa Villa Wrea Green has been brought to market (Image credit: The Villa Wrea Green)

For sale signs at The Villa

02 Apr 2025

4

Montane group expands with new Lancashire hub Anthony Rae Scott Murcott And Adam Lee

Montane group expands with new Lancashire hub

02 Apr 2025

5

Trio of wins for Lancaster brand and digital consultancy Tom Grattan MD and Daniel Wallace

Trio of wins for Lancaster brand and digital consultancy

02 Apr 2025

Pc Prestonmacan Gif980x120 March
Background image for hub sign up block

LBV Hub

Leverage Lancashire Business View platforms

Post your news
Post your events
Post your offers
Build your network
Improve your SEO
Gain coverage in the magazine
Sign-up
Events
Lancashire Net Zero Carbon Conference
Net Zero Carbon Social 1200px
Networking
18 Jun 2025

Lancashire Net Zero Carbon Conference

Crow Wood Hotel & Spa Resort, Burnley, BB12 0RT

08:30 - 13:00

CMI Level 5 Project Management Course
UCLanAerialCampus.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
21 Feb 2025 - 21 Feb 2026

CMI Level 5 Project Management Course

Preston Campus, Preston, PR1 2HE

08:00 - 17:00

CMI Level 5 Management and Leadership Course
UCLanAerialCampus.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
21 Feb 2025 - 21 Feb 2026

CMI Level 5 Management and Leadership Course

Preston Campus, Preston , PR1 2HE

09:00 - 17:00

RISE - The Academy for Female Leaders and Managers
WENDY BOWERS RISE Illustrstion copy.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
02 Apr 2025 - 08 Oct 2025

RISE - The Academy for Female Leaders and Managers

East Lancashire Chamber of Commerce, Clayton le Moors, BB5 5JR

09:00 - 15:30

Lancashire Business Expo 2025
https---cdn.evbuc.com-images-880395853-4862066883-1-original.20241022-091152-2.jpeg.jpg
LBV Hub Exhibitions
04 Apr 2025 - 04 Apr 2025

Lancashire Business Expo 2025

Sir Tom Finney Sports Centre, Preston, PR1 2HE

09:00 - 15:00

The Business Network Central & East Lancashire
LBV Hub Networking
24 Apr 2025 - 24 Apr 2025

The Business Network Central & East Lancashire

Stanley House, Blackburn, BB2 7NP

11:30 - 14:15

People Power: Exclusive Event Series
Stay ahead in 2025.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Seminars
29 Apr 2025 - 29 Apr 2025

People Power: Exclusive Event Series

People's History Museum, Manchester, M3 3ER

17:00 - 21:00

Planning for the future + navigating Inheritance Tax changes
Planning for the future + navigating Inheritance Tax changes for website.png.png
LBV Hub Seminars
01 May 2025 - 01 May 2025

Planning for the future + navigating Inheritance Tax changes

Stanley House Hotel, Mellor, Blackburn, BB2 7NP, Blackburn, BB2 7NP

08:00 - 10:30

A night at the races
1.png.png
LBV Hub Dinners / Balls
02 May 2025 - 02 May 2025

A night at the races

Morecambe FC, Morecambe, LA4 4TB

19:00 - 23:59

Amber River True Bearing quarterly investment seminar
LBV Hub Seminars
22 May 2025 - 22 May 2025

Amber River True Bearing quarterly investment seminar

Cottons Hotel & Spa , Knutsford, WA16 0SU

16:00 - 18:00

Liverpool Business Expo 2025
https---cdn.evbuc.com-images-881365363-4862066883-1-original.20241023-085714.jpeg.jpg
LBV Hub Awards
23 May 2025 - 23 May 2025

Liverpool Business Expo 2025

Aintree Racecourse , Liverpool , L9 5AS

09:00 - 15:00

National Centre for Remote and Rural Medicine Conference 2025
Remote and Rural 3.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Awards
05 Jun 2025 - 05 Jun 2025

National Centre for Remote and Rural Medicine Conference 2025

North Lakes Hotel and Spa, Penrith, CA11 8QT

09:30 - 17:00

Advertise with us

Reaching 50,000 members, our print, digital and event platforms offer a fantastic way to raise your business profile and help you grow.

Find out more Lbv121 Online Graphic
Subscribe now

Weekly news bulletin