Miliband's university fees plan would kill aspiration

Ed Miliband’s proposal to fund a reduction in university fees by raiding private pension pots will kill off aspiration in the young and has been branded “bonkers” by a Lancashire business advisory and accountancy firm.

Chartered accountant and business development specialist, John Toon, of Blackburn based, Pierce Group, one of the county's largest independent accountancy businesses, believes that Mr Miliband’s plans will be wholly counter-productive by not only creating a funding crisis for higher education but by stifling the future prospects and earnings potential of the very students he professes to support.

In a blog on the subject, he echoes the comments of Money Saving Expert’s Martin Lewis, who has called Ed Miliband’s suggestion, “financially illiterate.” He commented: “University graduates are the most likely to gain careers with salaries that will put them in the higher earnings tax bracket. And, under the new Auto Enrolment pensions’ policy, they’d be required to put 5 per cent of their earnings into a pension for the rest of their working life, yet on higher annual earnings, they would lose around hundreds of pounds each year if pensions’ tax relief is abolished as a consequence of the Labour leader’s proposal to pay for the reduction in tuition fees this way.

“The question I would ask as a student is, do I want my tuition fees reducing now by a third, or do I want to pay say a year on year penalty on my future earnings for life, if I’m fortunate enough to achieve my earnings potential. For me it would be a no-brainer but the only way to avoid the loss of tax relief would be for me to lower my horizons and settle for less from my career. It’s utterly bonkers, because it’s robbing people of aspiration. After all, what’s the point of gaining a university education, if not for the potential for higher earnings and better prospects? To then have those earnings penalised, just to pay for a modest reduction in tuition fees is anti-aspiration and shows the idea simply hasn’t been thought through.” Mr Toon also points out that students benefiting from reduced tuition fees under any future Labour government would still have to service their student loan debt if they earn above the threshold of £21,000 per year and suggests they would actually be worse off in the long-term than they would be if tuition fees remain at their current level and pension tax relief is retained. The consequences for higher education, he suggests, could also be serious in that some courses might be lost, particularly those in fields such as engineering and science where universities incur considerable costs for equipment and materials.

Enjoyed this? Read more from Pierce CA Ltd

Latest news

1

Barnfield Construction transitions to an Employee-Owned Business Staff Cheer Photo.jpg.jpg

Barnfield Construction transitions to an Employee-Owned Business

24 Jan 2025

2

Wallsauce looks to grow B2B customer base with increased trade focus Martin Emmott Rosebud and Andy Gerraty Wallsauce

Wallsauce looks to grow B2B customer base with increased trade focus

24 Jan 2025

3

CBP goes into administration Community and Business Partners in Blackburn with doors shut

CBP goes into administration

23 Jan 2025

4

Plan moves forward for new £13.2m Innovation Hub Councillor Phillippa Williamson and Coun Aidy Riggott

Plan moves forward for new £13.2m Innovation Hub

22 Jan 2025

5

Record turnover as Napthens continues to grow Stephen Faulkner

Record turnover as Napthens continues to grow

22 Jan 2025

Background image for hub sign up block

LBV Hub

Leverage Lancashire Business View platforms

Post your news
Post your events
Post your offers
Build your network
Improve your SEO
Gain coverage in the magazine
Sign-up
Events
The Lancashire Festival of Business
FOB 315
Exhibitions
30 Jan 2025

The Lancashire Festival of Business

Impact Conferencing, Burnley, BB12 6QP

09:30 - 16:00

Skills Bootcamp in Procurement - Cohort 3
Blue-Modern-Land-Travel-Youtube-Thumbnail-2-1024x576.png.png
LBV Hub Awards
14 Jan 2025 - 18 Mar 2025

Skills Bootcamp in Procurement - Cohort 3

Community & Business Partners CIC, Blackburn, BB2 3UA

09:30 - 13:00

North West Holiday Home Show
PLG - NWHHS - Social - Jan 2024.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Exhibitions
18 Jan 2025 - 26 Jan 2025

North West Holiday Home Show

South Lakeland House Showground, Yealand Redmayne, LA5 9RN

09:00 - 14:58

The Marketing Meetup IRL: Lancashire
LBV Hub Event Image.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
30 Jan 2025 - 30 Jan 2025

The Marketing Meetup IRL: Lancashire

Strawberry Fields Digital Hub, Chorley, PR7 1PS

18:00 - 20:00

Police Apprenticeship event
Student Centre Autumn 2022.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Social
12 Feb 2025 - 12 Jan 2025

Police Apprenticeship event

University of Central Lancashire, Foster Social Space , Preston , PR1 2HE

16:00 - 19:00

February Preston Tech Connection Meet-Up: Tech & Our Planet
PRESTON TECH CONNECTION jan.ai.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
12 Feb 2025 - 12 Feb 2025

February Preston Tech Connection Meet-Up: Tech & Our Planet

Society1 Coworking Space, Preston, PR1 3LT

18:00 - 19:30

The Business Network Central & East Lancashire
LBV Hub Networking
13 Feb 2025 - 13 Feb 2025

The Business Network Central & East Lancashire

Mytton Fold, Langho, BB6 8AB

11:30 - 14:15

Sub36 Networking - Behind the beans
Sub36 Social1200Atkinsons New
Networking
14 Feb 2025

Sub36 Networking - Behind the beans

Atkinsons Speciality Coffee, Lancaster, LA1 1 EX

09:00 - 11:30

Red Rose Awards 2025
Red Rose Awards 2025
Awards
13 Mar 2025

Red Rose Awards 2025

Winter Gardens Blackpool

18:00 - 11:59

Lancashire Business Day 2025
241122lbvlancashiredaylhp0647web
Networking
27 Nov 2025

Lancashire Business Day 2025

12:00 - 17:00

Advertise with us

Reaching 50,000 members, our print, digital and event platforms offer a fantastic way to raise your business profile and help you grow.

Find out more LBV120 Online Graphic 1
Subscribe now

Weekly news bulletin